14 Not Too Scary Horror Movies

Are you in the mood for a chillingly good time but not quite ready to dive under the covers at the slightest creak of a floorboard? Then you’re in luck! Our carefully curated selection keeps the thrill without sending the chills down your spine. Prepare to enter the realm of suspense and psychological twists with our list of 14 Not Too Scary Horror Movies that guarantee an intense experience sans the jumpscares or traumatic tales. On tap, we’ve got everything from stories of eerie disappearances to bizarre transformations. Welcome to the realm of goosebumps without the night terrors!

14. Uncanny Harbor

Immerse yourself in a surreal seaside town where the otherworldly lurks around every corner in Uncanny Harbor. Centered around a mysterious disappearance, this movie showcases Arthur, a reclusive fisherman, pitted against the cold truth about his wife’s vanishing two decades ago. Dive into this intense story of recollections and revelations without worrying about getting the heebie-jeebies! This fisherman’s tale is about to give your night an eerie yet intriguing undertone.

Watch Uncanny Harbor on Reveel

13. Threshold

Navigating the nebulous line between reality and fiction, Threshold delves into the world of an agoraphobic voice actress. Her world of solitude rapidly descends into torment due to the presence of a stranger in her safe space. This film perfectly maintains a feeling of suspense and vaguely disturbing undercurrent that never tips over into outright horror, making it the perfect inclusion on this list of not too scary horror movies.

Watch Threshold on Reveel

12. Guesthouse

Guesthouse transports you to an isolated location where a mother and her son find themselves check-in for the night. But remember, you are better off not finding yourself at this guesthouse. This film leverages the surroundings to create an unnerving atmosphere, driving up the suspense without resorting to shocking scares. It’s a truly psychological experience, ensuring your comfort zone is gently but firmly nudged.

Watch Guesthouse on Reveel

11. The Backwater Gospel

Unearth the secrets of a doomed town in ‘The Backwater Gospel’. The inhabitant’s lives are routinely disrupted by visits from a shadowy figure, The Undertaker. As despair seeps into their hearts, they turn their blame onto an innocent tramp. This multi-awarded short film is a product of The Animation Workshop, drenched in a distinctive visual style and a grim narrative, carefully seasoned with black humour. It’s no wonder this film has garnered wide-scale praise, marked further by the haunting tunes of Death Country legends Sons of Perdition.

Watch The Backwater Gospel on Reveel

10. Hang Up!

Channeling the Shakespearean tradition of villain monologues, Hang Up! spins an unsuspecting husband into a secretive and increasingly dark conversation. It all starts with an accidental butt dial revealing a side of his loving wife that he never imagined. The conversation’s morbid intrigue rivals the treacherous scheming of some of Shakespeare’s most notorious villains, including Macbeth, Richard the 3rd and Iago. For those seeking minimal scare but maximum psychological twists, this movie brings a unique modern-day horror, subtly exposing the anxieties of contemporary marriage. This drama also functions as a cautionary tale about curiosity that dives too deep, pulling viewers in without the trauma of jump scares.

Watch Hang Up! on Reveel

9. Cage

Step on the scary-side yet remaining in the caution zone with Cage, a suspenseful ride without the jumpscares. The plot orbits around Gracie Blake, a Seattle chat lines worker who agrees to a ‘one night only’ personal visit from a client. This decision catapults her life in an unexpected trajectory, leaving her fighting for survival in a cage, somewhere in America. This hair-raising narrative is filled with enough thrill to keep you hooked without throwing your peaceful sleep out of the window.

Watch Cage on Reveel

8. P

Following the journey of an orphan girl from rural Thailand, “P” expertly blends elements of the supernatural with the harsh realities of life. Taught the ways of magic by her grandmother, the young girl heads to Bangkok, drawn by promises of work. However, it turns out to be a seedy gogo bar where innocence can become a dangerous thing to lose. The film delicately balances unsettling themes with a fragile human story, proving that even the world of horror movies can hold deep emotional resonance.

Watch P on Reveel

7. Darwins Law

Darwins Law takes you on an intense journey with Agent Scott Taylor, who is investigating an illegal killer online game with the same name. In a thrilling turn of events, Taylor disappears and finds himself a part of the very game he was trying to take down. With suspense woven into its narrative, the movie captures the essence of a thrilling horror without pushing you off the edge of your comfort zone.

Watch Darwins Law on Reveel

6. Grotesque

Witness as the timid Mildred Moyer morphs into a captivating sociopath in ‘Grotesque.’ After a disfiguring back-alley plastic surgery runs awry, Mildred seeks vengeance against those who’ve made her feel small and tormented her in the past. Mildred’s metamorphoses from a shy wallflower to a captivating sociopath is beautifully horrifying, turning the conventional beauty standards on their heads. Even though this film has its brutal moments, we promise, no jumpscares. It’s sure to impress without causing you any hair-raising fear.

Watch Grotesque on Reveel

5. Metamorphosis (2022)

A failing marriage leads a couple to seek solace on an island in Upstate New York where they expect serenity, the kind that would adamantly salvage their deteriorating relationship. Little did they know that a horrifying ordeal was in the offing. The husband regresses, not just emotionally or mentally, but physically he simplifies into something they never saw coming, something entirely unrecognizable. Could their retreat be a cure or a grotesque curse? Experience spine-tingling suspense with Metamorphosis.

Watch Metamorphosis on Reveel

4. Chariot

An intense psychological thriller, Chariot weaves an enigmatic tale that will hook you from the start. Here, seven strangers awaken on a passenger jet, without any memory of how they got there or where they’re headed. This eerie premise leads us into a world of twists and turns, in a story that mirrors some of today’s headline news. The film features a sterling performance by Anthony Montgomery, best known from “Star Trek: Enterprise”.

Watch Chariot on Reveel

3. Rock Paper Scissors

Throwing a peaceful suburban life into a terrifying tailspin, Rock Paper Scissors digs into the raw aftermath of a savage home invasion. As a couple is pushed to the edge, their uneventful marriage gets a dark twist. How much are they willing to go through to reclaim their bond? The line between victim and predator gradually blurs in this movie’s twisted dive into revenge and marital relations.

Watch Rock Paper Scissors on Reveel

2. Mr. Lockjaw

Mr. Lockjaw tells the dark and eerie tale of Miles Brimley, a children’s performer who finds himself caught in an underworld of crime and torment. However, this is not your typical horror film. This psychologically twisted plot does away with the conventional gore and scare tactics, focusing instead on a morbidly intriguing ventriloquist-dummy dynamic. In between Miles’ innocent beginnings and unnerving end, lies a series of gripping events that keep you at the edge of your seat, without giving you reason to hide behind it.

Watch Mr. Lockjaw on Reveel

1. Suburban Nightmare

Suburban Nightmare takes you into the heart of a family desperate to make ends meet. An online rental app becomes their seeming savior as they open their home to guests in need of a place to stay. However, their seemingly perfect solution takes an eerie twist when an arrival turns out to have a violent past. As the suspense of this psychological thriller unfolds, brace yourself for a nerve-wracking ride.

Watch Suburban Nightmare on Reveel